Medical malpractice cases require substantial evidence to prove that healthcare providers did not meet accepted standards of care. Understanding Missouri's evidence requirements can help you take the correct steps to protect your legal rights and build the strongest possible case. Below, Fowler Pickert Eisenmenger Norfleet’s experienced malpractice evidence lawyers discuss proof requirements and the key types of evidence that form the foundation of successful medical malpractice claims.
Medical Records Form the Foundation of Your Case
Medical records are the primary evidence in any medical malpractice claim. These documents provide a detailed timeline and reveal whether healthcare providers followed appropriate protocols.
-
Complete medical records include hospital charts, physician notes, test results, imaging studies, and medication records from all relevant providers.
-
Obtaining comprehensive medical records requires requesting files from every healthcare facility and provider involved in your care.
-
The timing of record requests matters significantly. Healthcare facilities may destroy older records according to their retention policies, making prompt action essential.
Expert Testimony Establishes the Standard of Care
Missouri law requires expert medical testimony in most malpractice cases to establish what constitutes appropriate care and how the defendant's actions fell short. These experts must be qualified physicians who practice or have practiced in the same specialty as the defendant and can explain the relevant medical standards of care to a jury.
-
Expert witnesses must be licensed to practice medicine and have sufficient experience in the relevant medical field.
-
Courts may exclude testimony from experts who lack appropriate qualifications or whose opinions aren't based on reliable medical principles.
Documentation of Damages Proves Your Losses
Comprehensive documentation of damages is essential medical malpractice evidence needed to determine the value of your case. Proper documentation helps establish the full extent of your injuries and their impact on your life. Missouri law allows recovery for both economic losses, such as medical expenses and lost wages, and non-economic damages, including pain and suffering.
-
Medical bills and treatment records provide evidence of economic damages resulting from the malpractice.
-
Employment records and wage statements demonstrate lost income resulting from your injuries.
-
Evidence of pain and suffering may include personal journals documenting your daily struggles, photos of visible injuries, and testimony from family members.
-
Experts may need to testify about ongoing treatment needs and costs and provide detailed projections of future medical expenses.
Witness Statements Support Your Version of Events
Witness testimony, which offers firsthand accounts of the care you received, can provide crucial support for your medical malpractice case. It should be obtained as soon as possible after the incident.
-
Family members who were present during medical treatment can testify about what they observed and heard.
-
Healthcare workers who witnessed the malpractice may provide powerful testimony about substandard care or conversations they heard among medical personnel.
-
Other patients who received care from the same provider might have experienced similar problems and may be able to testify about concerning practices they observed.
-
Expert witnesses in related fields can provide testimony about policies that should have been followed and how proper protocols would have prevented your injuries.
Internal Documents Reveal Institutional Knowledge
Healthcare facilities create various internal documents that can provide valuable evidence in malpractice cases. However, obtaining internal documents typically requires formal discovery requests or subpoenas, as healthcare facilities rarely volunteer this kind of information.
-
Incident reports document unusual occurrences or adverse events, potentially revealing that the facility was aware of problems with your care.
-
Quality assurance records show how healthcare facilities monitor and evaluate the care provided by their staff and how the facility has addressed any known safety issues.
-
Personnel records for the healthcare providers involved in your care may reveal relevant information about their training, credentials, disciplinary history, and track record.
-
Hospital policies and procedures manuals establish the standards that staff members are supposed to follow.
-
Training records can show whether staff members received proper instruction on relevant procedures.
Photographic and Physical Evidence Documents the Harm
Visual evidence can powerfully demonstrate the extent of injuries and substandard care. Prompt action is essential, as this type of evidence often disappears or deteriorates if not properly preserved.
-
Photos of surgical sites, medical devices, or visible injuries help juries understand the severity of malpractice consequences. These images should be taken as soon as possible after the incident, as conditions may change rapidly with treatment or healing.
-
Medical devices or equipment, such as defective implants or contaminated instruments, involved in the malpractice may provide physical evidence of medical negligence.
-
Pathology slides and tissue samples may be crucial for medical experts to review in cases involving misdiagnosis or surgical errors.
-
Diagnostic images such as X-rays, CT scans, and MRIs reveal objective evidence of medical conditions and treatment outcomes, and may have been misinterpreted.